The Trouble with Jesus

by Constance Hastings

When Good News is Your Bad News
December 11, 2023

The Trouble with Jesus is light shining in darkness

is not always received as good news.

Now remember this, the poor guy couldn’t help himself. Yeah, he was a little strange, weird even, in how he dressed and lived. That kind of thing though can be changed with some help from people who care. Then again, his parents were OLD when he was born, so he likely had lived for quite some time on his own. His early years were mostly around the religious kind, so he’d been indoctrinated with all the ancient writings. Again, a little education can give a different perspective. But about this, there was no way around it, away from it, just through it.

 

JTB was sent. Get that? Sent. And with that, there was a compulsion. He, for the most part, lived in the wilderness, the kind of place where when nothing good is around you, God shows up. In the uninhabitable, forbidding, empty regions of life, God speaks to the soul. To John the Baptist, a message had been given there. He was sent to proclaim it.

 

In the Bleak Midwinter

Light shines in darkness! Right there, in this bleak territory, John shouted a message that there was light for the people. The One who would change life was coming; One who would bring the hope, peace and even the joy one needs to not just live but thrive in this existence. Light has the unstoppable characteristic of shining in the most dubious places, those parts that are not familiar with truth and clarity. Whatever wrong and negative setting or context sits in the shadows is forced to change, reconcile, reverse itself in the bright gleam—or hide itself deeper in the recesses it inhabits.

 

Light shines in the darkness! In the dark place of wilderness, people came to hear this message from the one sent by God. They had been waiting for such a messenger, waiting actually for centuries to be delivered from this life that had dashed hope, destroyed peace and held no joy. So they came to hear this strange guy in this wilderness place, to hear and prepare for the One he said would soon come.

 

Light shines in the darkness! They came to hear the message, and the crowd it attracted was noticed by those for whom this good news was maybe not such good news. For those who held the power, for those who thought they were the ones God should have given the message, for those whose true motives the Light revealed, this was not good news. It was dangerous.

 

They had to check it out. Now some others were sent, but this time from those who had a lot to lose by John’s message. Oh, they looked like the good guys, priests and assistants in the Temple. Yet, it was in the asking they revealed themselves.

 

Interrogation

So the grilling began. Their questions come with rapid fire, likely surrounding him with their powerful presence. Anyone who’s been tied to a chair with an intense lamp in the face knows what they were about. This poor guy who’s got nothing to his name except an intense belief in a God whom they will never know is drilled.

 

“Are you the Messiah?” He flatly denies it.

“Who are you? Elijah? The Prophet?” He insists, “NO. NO.”

 

They change the tactic. “Tell us, so we can give an answer to those who sent us. What do you have to say about yourself?” Come on, guy. Work with us here. You help us and we can help you.

 

He tells them what they already know. “I am a voice shouting in the wilderness, ‘Prepare a straight pathway for the Lord’s coming!’” (Isaiah 40:3)

 

Make it easy on him. Challenge what he’s doing. Discredit him in front of the people. Reveal him for the lunatic he is. If he isn’t the one the ancient writings said would precede the Messiah, then he’s just a nobody. A nobody with no right to baptize or call people to prepare themselves because there’s no one coming. Forget this guy. “If you aren’t the Messiah [or any of the other prophets], what right do you have to baptize?”

 

Warning in the Promise

John knows who he is, and John knows the One who sent him. He tells it like it is. The Coming One is here, and you know what, I’m not worthy to even bow to him as a servant and remove his sandals. In other words, if you are threatened by me and this message, if your phony positions won’t stand up in the face of this declaration, if I scare you in the least, then here’s your bad news. Someone is coming after me who’s going to really upset this scene and who will reveal you for what you are not. Light shines in the darkness!

 

JTB, you won that round. You couldn’t help it. You were chosen and sent so the people would be ready, have it on their radar that God was on the move. The old stories of a new day were about to come true, happen right before their eyes. The season of preparation, expectation, change, and reversal was now! Light shines in the darkness!

 

Good News/Bad News

Yes. The religious leaders left to give their appraisal of this desert mystic. But. The stage was set, the lines were drawn, the watch began. Good news for those who would find new, abundant, eternal life in God by following the Coming One also meant bad news for his messenger. John would eventually lose his life for this proclamation.

 

He wouldn’t be the only one. Throughout the centuries of all time, when authority is threatened or when a message is declared that upsets the status quo, the messenger must be stopped. Whoever displaces the influencers and controllers or whatever breaks down the supremacy of one group over another must be silenced. When lifestyle changes are required, when personal self is valued above the greater good, when power must give way to the powerless, that voice must be polluted. Darkness is the fate of those sent with good news that life can be otherwise.

 

Yet the message itself never does stop. Two thousand years, and Light shines in the darkness still. The message points to the Coming One. Hope, Peace, and Joy still are possible. That is the Good News.

 

John 1:6-8,19-28 

 

Subscribe to The Trouble with Jesus Blog Here. 





The Trouble with Jesus : He refuses to meet our expectations, not the other way around.
By Constance Hastings August 8, 2026
Let me tell you straight: if there’s a portrayal of Jesus I hate reading, it’s this one. The one that makes you squirm, makes you hunt for excuses you know don’t exist (like who could ever excuse the Son of God?), or forces you to wrestle with the truth, swallowing stuff you never want to admit...
The Trouble with Jesus: He calls people to walk with him right into a bad storm.
By Constance Hastings August 3, 2026
When the road breaks open and unthinkable obstacles appear on the path, when innate ability and skill are erased and “No Way” is the biggest sign in the road, when risks feels like it’ll cost your whole soul, what then? Inevitably, storms hit, flip your whole world, and what was a smooth sail gets tossed like a toy...
The Trouble with Jesus: Miracles hit when what’s small is shared and becomes more than enough.
By Constance Hastings July 27, 2026
It was a long day, and in wanting to care for their rabbi as well as dissipate the crowd, the disciples tell Jesus to send them into the villages to buy food for an evening meal. That’s when Jesus snapped...
The Trouble with Jesus: Jesus   contrasts what should be against what is not.
By Constance Hastings July 20, 2026
You can’t say Jesus ever made it easy...He required challenge, debate and wrestling with his teachings beyond what makes you feel comfortable.
The Trouble with Jesus:  He proposes both good and evil exist side by side for now.
By Constance Hastings July 13, 2026
“The Kingdom of Heaven is like…” The two seeds, good seed and the bad seed which would choke out the good seed, are permitted to exist side by side until end of the world....If you’ve read this parable story as one of God’s condemnation on the evil in the world, slow down. Be very careful....
a
By Constance Hastings July 11, 2026
“I do not cease to give thanks for you as I remember you in my prayers.” Ephesians 1:16
The Trouble with Jesus: He calls out those who think they can play in the dirt and not get dirty.
By Constance Hastings July 6, 2026
If you push past some religious snobbery and gatekeeping here, Jesus’ parable about a farmer who scatters seed is going to be a real challenge on more than one level…. Anyone out there ever thinking, “I’m saved, I’m good,” ticket to heaven punched, you’re in, and that’s all you need? Then this parable is NOT for you
The Trouble with Jesus: He did not refrain from using images that oppose each other.
By Constance Hastings June 29, 2026
You’re either going to love it or hate it. And trust me, you’re not the only one wrestling with it. The Bible, Holy Scriptures, God’s Word, Gospel, or whatever name you want to slap on it, isn’t built for folks who want a warm blanket and a bedtime story...
The Trouble with Jesus:Extend what little one has to the little ones and all ones.
By Constance Hastings June 22, 2026
It’s wild out there right now, one side screaming at another, the whole world split in half. You may be feeling if you don’t choose a side, you’ll get caught in the middle with both sides pounding you instead of just one. No lie. The world’s grimy, petty, and straight-up dangerous, no doubt about it. Jesus warned them…
The Trouble with Jesus: Following him requires  your reordering your life and relationships.
By Constance Hastings June 15, 2026
Here’s a safe bet you won’t hear these words preached on Sunday. Even if Jesus did say them, they wouldn’t sit well for a sermon on Father’s Day. Nah, Pastors will be spouting, “Honor your dad,” those who have raised us to be good people, godly people, fathers who give so much of their life and love for their children.
The Trouble with Jesus : He refuses to meet our expectations, not the other way around.
By Constance Hastings August 8, 2026
Let me tell you straight: if there’s a portrayal of Jesus I hate reading, it’s this one. The one that makes you squirm, makes you hunt for excuses you know don’t exist (like who could ever excuse the Son of God?), or forces you to wrestle with the truth, swallowing stuff you never want to admit...
The Trouble with Jesus: He calls people to walk with him right into a bad storm.
By Constance Hastings August 3, 2026
When the road breaks open and unthinkable obstacles appear on the path, when innate ability and skill are erased and “No Way” is the biggest sign in the road, when risks feels like it’ll cost your whole soul, what then? Inevitably, storms hit, flip your whole world, and what was a smooth sail gets tossed like a toy...
The Trouble with Jesus: Miracles hit when what’s small is shared and becomes more than enough.
By Constance Hastings July 27, 2026
It was a long day, and in wanting to care for their rabbi as well as dissipate the crowd, the disciples tell Jesus to send them into the villages to buy food for an evening meal. That’s when Jesus snapped...
The Trouble with Jesus: Jesus   contrasts what should be against what is not.
By Constance Hastings July 20, 2026
You can’t say Jesus ever made it easy...He required challenge, debate and wrestling with his teachings beyond what makes you feel comfortable.
The Trouble with Jesus:  He proposes both good and evil exist side by side for now.
By Constance Hastings July 13, 2026
“The Kingdom of Heaven is like…” The two seeds, good seed and the bad seed which would choke out the good seed, are permitted to exist side by side until end of the world....If you’ve read this parable story as one of God’s condemnation on the evil in the world, slow down. Be very careful....
a
By Constance Hastings July 11, 2026
“I do not cease to give thanks for you as I remember you in my prayers.” Ephesians 1:16
The Trouble with Jesus: He calls out those who think they can play in the dirt and not get dirty.
By Constance Hastings July 6, 2026
If you push past some religious snobbery and gatekeeping here, Jesus’ parable about a farmer who scatters seed is going to be a real challenge on more than one level…. Anyone out there ever thinking, “I’m saved, I’m good,” ticket to heaven punched, you’re in, and that’s all you need? Then this parable is NOT for you
The Trouble with Jesus: He did not refrain from using images that oppose each other.
By Constance Hastings June 29, 2026
You’re either going to love it or hate it. And trust me, you’re not the only one wrestling with it. The Bible, Holy Scriptures, God’s Word, Gospel, or whatever name you want to slap on it, isn’t built for folks who want a warm blanket and a bedtime story...
The Trouble with Jesus:Extend what little one has to the little ones and all ones.
By Constance Hastings June 22, 2026
It’s wild out there right now, one side screaming at another, the whole world split in half. You may be feeling if you don’t choose a side, you’ll get caught in the middle with both sides pounding you instead of just one. No lie. The world’s grimy, petty, and straight-up dangerous, no doubt about it. Jesus warned them…
The Trouble with Jesus: Following him requires  your reordering your life and relationships.
By Constance Hastings June 15, 2026
Here’s a safe bet you won’t hear these words preached on Sunday. Even if Jesus did say them, they wouldn’t sit well for a sermon on Father’s Day. Nah, Pastors will be spouting, “Honor your dad,” those who have raised us to be good people, godly people, fathers who give so much of their life and love for their children.