The Trouble with Jesus

by Constance Hastings

Messy Faith
September 2, 2024

The Trouble with Jesus is he gets messy with what we are like

even as he meets us in what we need.

This week’s reading tells again of an incident I’d prefer to move beyond. Worse yet, it relates a glimpse into Jesus’ life for the second time. If it’s bad enough to be told once, why does it have to be rehearsed again? But both the writers of Mark and Matthew want it told and don’t leave out the graphic details some would prefer to excuse, that is, whitewash (deliberate word there) over. Even so, for the sake of what comes later, I invite you to read it here in blog form, A Dogged Faith.  It is also found in a greater context in The Trouble with Jesus: Considerations Before You Walk Away, Chapter 2, pages 33-37, or available wherever you love to buy books.


Agreed. Whereas Jesus does the right thing in that part of his story, he doesn’t appear all lightning white when it’s over. Like the rest of us, learning what justice entails was a stretch for him, too. Either that, or maybe he shows how the struggle is real for all of us. Son of Man, how far are you going to take this?


Question: Not Can You, But Will You?

Stories of people bringing the sick to Jesus are not out of the ordinary. Even now, heaven probably shakes constantly with petitions for people to be healed. Give them some credit here. While prayers may come with sobs for God to reverse what could be the worst possible outcome, the proverbial faith of a mustard seed is the foundation of their cries. The heart knows or at least wants to believe that God can heal. The fear is, will God make this miracle or not? Still, we ask.


The Syrophenician woman begged and argued with Jesus out of that faith. Yet, in her context she knew she could be refused. Likewise, who are we to be so bold to ask for healing, anybody’s healing, in our own limited understanding of where we sit, what God sees beyond what we know. Even with modern day interventions and treatment, still sometimes prayer is the only recourse. So, we ask.


Another Place, Same Place

After this encounter, Jesus gets out of Dodge the best he can. Still, it’s a long way back from where he came. You know how news travels on the wind? People find him and the ask is the same. Heal this person.


Whereas the woman’s daughter was not present when her mother begged for help, this time a man’s friends brought him to Jesus. Again, they were not of his race, religion, or ethnicity. Didn’t matter. The man was deaf and mostly mute. He couldn’t know the difference, what could separate him from potential healing. For that matter though, his friends didn’t care either. Begging like desperate people, they asked Jesus to lay his hands on the man.


Big ask again. Touching sick people for the Jews would make one unclean and require extensive rituals to be restored. Guess that’s why Jesus led him to a private place away from the crowd. If this story was to be told, no need to bring up what one didn’t need to do the job. Interestingly though, there was no hesitation or argument on Jesus’ part this time.


An Intimate Exchange

Jesus had healed the woman’s daughter by remote, you could say. All it took were his words, “I have healed your daughter.” The girl was restored to physical, mental, spiritual health, just like that. Right in her own home. Nice and clean. Not so here.


After putting his fingers into the deaf man’s ears, Jesus spit into his own fingers and then touched the mute man’s tongue with it. With a deep sigh, he commanded, “Be opened!” and the man had perfect hearing and speech. More than messy, for certain. Miracles can be that way. God reaches inside to make needed changes.


The Follow Up

The first healing gets repeated, maybe so we can’t escape it, have to reckon with it. The second one is told just once, in six short verses. Interestingly, the people who learned of this tell it on their own, activating that viral wind again. One passage gets skipped over in Sunday preaching; the one following it is lifted up proclaiming, “just have faith people!” If Jesus sighed over one miracle, he must have been drained by both.


A Common Thread

Both the man and the little girl lived in settings which bring out racial and ethnic tensions in their contexts. The nice thing to say is that Jesus learned from one and wasn’t afraid to meet another’s desperation despite it. Use that if you have to. Yeah, keep it distant, out there, on him, not close.


Or…look into that central question. The prayer goes, “God, you can, but will you?” Beggars know there are resources to more than meet their needs, but will they be shared? These healings reveal how desperation makes beggars of us all, regardless of who we are, and of a healer willing to get messy with whatever faith we bring.


Mark 7:24-37


Subscribe to The Trouble with Jesus Blog Here.

The Trouble with Jesus: Even his stories from the shady side of life show what God desires.
By Constance Hastings September 16, 2025
The Trouble with Jesus; He will use whatever he can, even stories from the shady side of life, to get people to understand what God desires for the world.
The Trouble with Jesus: His stories make God look desperately unsatisfied, on the prowl for more.
By Constance Hastings September 8, 2025
The Trouble with Jesus: His stories make God look desperately unsatisfied, on the prowl for more, regardless of whether they’re lost or don’t know how lost they are.
The Trouble with Jesus: He made a life lesson on humility into a blessed honor.
By Constance Hastings August 31, 2025
Jesus, you are the perfect example of the observation, “When you are invited to a dinner, you are either a guest or you are part of a menu.” Everybody is always watching you, sizing you up, holding their breath to see what you might do next. You look like you’re there to eat as much as you’re there to preach.
The Trouble with Jesus: His rhetoric doesn’t permit a domestication of lifestyle covered by religion
By Constance Hastings August 25, 2025
The Trouble with Jesus: His scandalous rhetoric doesn’t permit domestication of lifestyle covered with a veneer of religion.
The Trouble with Jesus: ihe brings upheaval into how the world works, even when it hurts his cause
By Constance Hastings August 18, 2025
This reads like Jesus is being attacked for healing on the Sabbath. It's more than that which brings big trouble. Jesus was breaking Sabbath by breaking perceptions of what the social and religious structure of the world should be, wreaking and crumbling the caste system of the entire religious culture.
Truth Burns: The Trouble with Jesus is he makes political divisions look tame.
By Constance Hastings August 11, 2025
You know what, Jesus? This makes you certified dangerous. So you’re going to bring fire, division and family dysfunction? Like we need your divine help on this one. Incendiary talk won’t get you votes on making our world better. More like, arrested and put away for good. Yeah, you ask for it.
The Trouble with Jesus is he both brings and requires reversals.
By Constance Hastings August 4, 2025
Jesus. We need help. No, make that, you need help. Whatever. You spin this talk about treasure in heaven and then getting robbed. About being the revered master and then acting like you’re the slave. Come on here. Say what you mean and quit making it so hard for us to get it.
The Trouble with Jesus is he talks too much about your money.
By Constance Hastings July 28, 2025
It’s not the accumulation of wealth that’s the problem. You’re right though, Jesus had a lot to say about money. In some places he talks about it more than prayer. In the end, that being this blog and your life, it would pay for you to listen up to this story of The Rich Fool.
The Trouble with Jesus is he teaches God answers prayers by not always giving us what we ask.
By Constance Hastings July 21, 2025
Relationship is what God wants out of prayers and this is how God wants it understood. God and you have this thing going. You two need to talk. What follows is a structure to this particular prayer, the Lord's Prayer, but each part is a prayer unto itself. Talk it over with God where you are in it.
The Trouble with Jesus is he doesn’t take just one side.
By Constance Hastings July 14, 2025
Jesus, on this one we have to give it to you. You didn’t send Mary back to the kitchen just because she was a woman....Well, thanks, but not so fast. If you are assuming this is some kind of feminist liberation call, you’re two steps behind and five miles ahead. Jesus didn’t go around saying that kind of thing...