Blog Layout

 The Trouble with Jesus

by Constance Hastings

An Extreme Radicalization
Jan 31, 2022

The Trouble with Jesus:

you can’t ignore the changing political, economic and social scene.

It’s a story for the books, maybe a movie (ok, yeah, that’s been done already), but who really does this sort of thing? You’ve got to be really desperate to just take off, leave your job and family, and literally get behind a guy who says get on board with him, and he’ll show you how to fish for people. Wait just a second. People can stink worse than fish. I don’t know. What did they think they were getting into?

It had been another long night with nothing to show for it. He likely was a strong man, arms bulging with defined muscles, a complexion browner than his natural skin tone from a lifetime on the water. He wasn’t one of those chosen from Hebrew school to further his study. He’d had just enough religious education to make him a good Jew, one who kept the laws, participated in the festivals, and made sacrifices in the Temple. He’d been trained but not given choice in life to be who he wanted. He learned from his father how to fish, not because it was his passion, but because that’s how they made a living.


To his breed, hard manual labor was his lot in life, but every penny he earned was stained with strain and sweat. Though others were fed by his toil, he could be easily replaced with another brute of man who would slave his life away on the waters with late nights and heavy nets. Life was no more than hard work, limited choices, and death.

This morning was just another slap in the face. The cruel mercy of the sea had dealt him an empty hand that night, and now there was nothing to bring home to make life any easier for his family. Not a single fish. Simon and his partners knew their women would be disappointed; others would not be surprised. They never would amount to anything. Empty nets meant an empty soul sooner or later.

On the shore, that new rabbi was getting ready to speak to the crowds. OH, Great.  Now everyone for miles would know their failure. But Jesus motioned for them to come closer and asked for a boat. From a floating pulpit, his voice carried across the water with his message of good news for those gathered on the shore. But what kind of good news could there be for losers like him and his friends? Better to keep your distance.

Dangerous Man

Be forewarned. Jesus preached Good News. Due to that, millions support him. Even so, like these nobody watermen, you may sense there is something about him that could be dangerous.

Well, that’s a different take. So you’re being up front about what’s behind all of this? Uh huh, where you going with this? I’m just as leery about you as I’ve ever been about him. Though usually your kind is either pie-in-the-sky or predicting the end of the world. Why should I be careful approaching this dude?

That’s the point. It’s not so much about people looking for him as it is about how he finds them. Often, they are just living life as it’s supposed to be, and Jesus interrupts it. That’s when he is most dangerous.

Jesus made a bold request of Simon. “What? (Obviously this former carpenter didn’t know much about fishing.) You want us to go out now and drop the nets again? Don’t you know that fish feed at night, not in the middle of a hot morning?”


Even so, Simon did call him “Master” and out of respect for this popular preacher, he and his men push off in two boats again. Suddenly, the weight and pull on the ropes get stronger. Simon holds tight, realizing the nets could tear. With the strength of years between them, they pull and raise so many fish, the boats nearly sink from the weight.

Simon quickly realizes Jesus is not one of those ordinary teachers that go around the country preaching and collecting money. He innately understood this great catch was a reversal, what the prophets called a “sign.” Simon with his partners James and John, men not considered very intelligent, were at least smart enough to read this “sign” and be  amazed. Falling to his knees he begs, “Lord, leave me. I’m too much of a sinner to be around you.”

It had been beaten in him from both the synagogue and life circumstances that he wasn’t anything of worth, meant to be noticed or considered special. Beyond what little he could bring home on a good catch, no one would have given him any kind of recognition. That’s how the world was made; some got it all, the rest got what’s left over.

Jesus leans in. “Don’t be afraid. From now on you’ll be fishing for people.” With those words, Simon, James and John were granted a reversal greater than a boat-load full of fish. They were chosen for a new kind of life with a leader who would reverse their status and make them into what they never could be, men who spoke words from God that changed lives. No longer would they be considered the losers, the bottom-feeders, the ones lower than underdogs. Immediately, they dropped their lines and followed Jesus.

But what was life changing good news for them meant trouble for those who always looked down upon them, those of status and power.

The Making of a Revolution

To understand what Jesus was calling them to do,

you can’t ignore the changing political, economic and social scene.

When Caesar Augustus died, Tiberius became ruler of Rome. Herod Antipas knew what side of the bread the butter needed to be, so he built a new city on the Sea of Galilee and smartly named it, Tiberius. He had big plans for this new urban center, specifically the fishing industry. Doing what despots do, he saw to it that all fishing was controlled by the Romans. Taxes bit into everybody’s profits by requiring fishing permits, a sales tax on the product and its processing, and even enforcing toll taxes on its transport.

Don’t think this revenue was funneled back for the promotion and benefit of the people who did the hard work. Keeping these Jews marginalized and poor held the lid on them, so Rome was happy with that. Government infrastructure got a great boost from the project with building good roads and fantastic palaces. All in all, Herod had a good thing going here.

In the eyes of Rome, it’s what you do when there are dissonant voices against your reign. In reality, Herod’s agenda only heated the simmer against Rome. Add in the oppression against the fishing industry, and you easily could find people who were ready to make a stand. All they needed was a leader.

So are you saying Jesus really recruited these guys to a call to arms, so to speak? They thought they were signing into God’s army to overthrow the Romans and get their lives back? That’s not the usual narrative.

There’s the narrative, and then there’s the context of that narrative. People pull the details that enhance their own platforms. These men did not have a real clue as to the specifics of the plan. If they had, would they have gotten behind Jesus and the movement he was starting?

Who knows, but it does explain why for the next three years they seemed to be mistaken as to where this mission was leading. They had learned from their own history as God’s chosen people only by a mighty warrior could invaders be turned away. The ancient writings had said a Messiah was promised. More than ever, the people wanted that time to be now, and Jesus’ message made him a good candidate.

Radicalization

What gets wrapped in this story is the change Jesus would preach. Radical change, certainly, but not change brought about as before. Time and again, he tangled with the religious authorities who more often than not cow-towed to the political rule. What infuriated him was how they leveraged God to oppress the people as much as the Romans did with their heavy taxing.

But instead of raising an army and storming the Roman centers of power, Jesus preached loving neighbor and enemy , turning the other cheek, walking an extra mile, and being light in the darkness. In doing so, the prisoner would be released, the blind will see, and the oppressed freed from what chains them.

Such a movement would effect change, change greater than any charismatic leader, governmental edicts or religious laws could bring. Inherent in it is revolution that ascends above what no protest, demonstration, march, or rally could ever accomplish. Fishing for people involves a radicalization which reverses one’s relationships so as to honor God and care for others. By this, the rancor and divisions between people would lower, maybe even be removed, and bring about the Kingdom of God.

Jesus preached this because it is so much within all realms of possibility,

and if this change is embraced, it is Good News.

Luke 5:1-11

The Trouble with Jesus is he left his job undone, and he did it on purpose.
By Constance Hastings 08 May, 2024
They had no idea what they were getting into when he had recruited them for his purposes. Some say they weren’t the brightest bulbs on the street. The only attribute which spoke most for them was they were teachable…
The Trouble with Jesus: Was his prayer for unity  answered? It depends on where you look.
By Constance Hastings 07 May, 2024
You Christians! If ever there a more divisive movement in history, it’s yours! You people just can’t stay together. You guys just keep fighting among yourselves and splitting up and moving off in different directions. If you don’t like what’s going on in your church, you take your money and walk. Sometimes, a whole group of you jump ship and make your own deal somewhere else. There’s enough of this kind of thing going on; why would we ever need religion to show us how it’s done? May your God help you.
The Trouble with Jesus: No greater Love means laying down one’s life for friends.
By Constance Hastings 01 May, 2024
No greater love than this, to lay down one’s life for friends, is to daily relinquish the right to one’s self in service for others.
By an intimate conjoining of love, the True Vine connects with its branches.
By Constance Hastings 22 Apr, 2024
The Trouble with Jesus: His words grow like a vine, thin trails of thought getting thicker with meaning.
The Trouble with Jesus: even his sweet stories have an underlying tension.
By Constance Hastings 14 Apr, 2024
Awww, so sweet. A story about a good shepherd and his sheep. I can see now the old, faded pictures of this Jesus-figure carrying his lambs. Like really, what does this have to do with today? We left this kind of thing in the nursery with Mary’s little lamb. Baa-baa to you.
The Trouble with Jesus: Resurrection is the pivotal spin between doubt, wonder, and belief.
By Constance Hastings 08 Apr, 2024
Every single one of them did it. When they heard the news, they didn’t believe it. Don’t blame them. We are no different. To be honest, it helps. It helps a lot, for if the report was swallowed hook, line, and sinker as the fishermen they were, it’d be pretty evident this story was falsified with some ulterior purpose in mind, like fashioned to make themselves into some kind of holy heroes. Not how it happened. They didn’t believe it, plain and simple.
The Trouble with Jesus is faith must be linked with doubt to become belief.
By Constance Hastings 01 Apr, 2024
Could it be that faith is not actually a fully convinced mindset? Could it be that to truly have faith an element of doubt, perceptions that rest in possibly not as much as possibly so, is necessary? Do faith and doubt exist not as opposites but as integral parts of each other?
The Trouble with Jesus: No god does this sort of thing. Wonder.
By Constance Hastings 30 Mar, 2024
How do you get out of bed in the morning when the day is still shrouded in darkness? How do you rise when grief, anger, and anxious fear sink deep into your soul? Why should you open your eyes to a pain that pierces whatever faith that is left? Somehow, they did.
The Trouble with Jesus is he wasn’t betrayed by just one guy.
By Constance Hastings 27 Mar, 2024
. Before Jesus even got into town, they lined the road, spreading a carpet of coats and shouting, “Blessed is the King who comes in the name of the Lord.” Expectations were high. If only he had come to fulfill them....With too much popularity and too many attacks on the powers-that-be, Jesus wasn’t making it easy on himself. Sooner or later, someone was going to put a stop to this. As it was, it wasn’t just one.
The Trouble with Jesus is his love is  counter-cultural, an intimate, dangerous act of shared powe
By Constance Hastings 25 Mar, 2024
It’s hard to allow the less attractive parts of ourselves be exposed, let alone the parts which stink, with warts, bunions, and fungus embedded in the nails. Equally difficult is to accept it from one of whom we think so highly, even worship.... Worse yet, maybe they know us better than we think, better than we know ourselves. Their goodness shouldn’t be sullied with our mean stuff, the secret knowledge of ourselves. Why does God have to come so close?
More Posts
Share by: